Fiftieth Anniversary Issue*
November 2026 • Free
Circulation: one pan
Paul's Pumpkin Bars
There are 24. Go ahead and take one.
The Recipe
One bowl of wet, one bowl of dry, one ungreased pan.
Here's the recipe, at the top, where a recipe belongs. It's the 1976 formula as the magazine printed it:1 24 bars, 25 to 30 minutes at 350°F in a 15×10×1-inch pan, with cream cheese frosting once they've cooled. Change the batch, the frosting or the units and every number on the page updates to match, including the cost per bar.
From the kitchen of
Paul
- Makes
- 24 bars
- Pan
- 15×10
- Oven
- 350°F
- Bake
- 25–30 min
- Hands-on
- 20 min
Ingredients
For the bars
For the frosting
Method
Heat and soften
Oven to 350°F (175°C). Leave the 15×10×1-inch jelly-roll pan ungreased. Set the cream cheese and butter on the counter now so they are soft by the time you need them.
Whisk the dry
In a medium bowl whisk 2 cups flour, 2 tsp baking powder, 2 tsp cinnamon, 1 tsp baking soda and ½ tsp salt.
Beat the wet
In a large bowl beat 4 eggs, 1 can (15 oz) pumpkin, 1⅔ cups sugar and 1 cup oil until light and fluffy.
Combine
Add the dry to the wet and beat until well combined. Stir in 1 cup chopped pecans.
Spread and bake
Spread the batter evenly in the 15×10×1-inch jelly-roll pan. Bake 25 to 30 minutes, until a toothpick in the center comes out clean. (A 9×13 works too: thicker, cakier, about 30 minutes.)
Let it cool all the way
Set the pan on a rack and leave it alone until it's fully cool, usually about an hour. Frosting a warm bar gets you a glaze, and not a good one.
Make the frosting
Beat 3 oz cream cheese, ¼ cup butter and 1 tsp vanilla until fluffy, then beat in 2 cups powdered sugar a little at a time until smooth.
Frost and cut
Spread the frosting to the edges, scatter with more pecans and cut into 24 bars. Anything left over goes in the fridge, though the magazine didn't expect there to be any.
Cutting the Pan
How many bars is a pan of bars?
The magazine said 24, but the magazine isn't the one holding the knife.
What a Pan Costs
Legend has it Paul was an accountant.3
So I did his books. The prices are rough U.S. grocery guesses; type over them with what's on your receipt and the cost per bar reconciles itself.
| Item | You buy | Price | Used | Cost |
|---|
Depreciation of pan: not material. Labor: donated. Bars eaten before frosting: off the books.
Timeline of an Urban Legend
Fifty years of retyping, and no two copies agree.
Paul's bars have been copied into recipe binders, tips sites and food blogs, and nearly everyone changed something on the way. Below is the version history, compared line by line with the original.1
Five numbers that every copy leaves alone:
- 4 eggs
- 1⅔ cups sugar
- 1 cup oil
- 1 can pumpkin
- 2 cups flour
Frosting inflation, 1976 → now
It's the same pan and the same cake, now carrying two to four times the frosting, depending on the ingredient.5
Who the heck is Paul?
Here's the story part, and yes, it comes after the recipe. It isn't a story about me. It's a question I can't stop asking: a great many people have baked this man's pumpkin bars, and I can't find one who has met him.
What's on paper is thin. Better Homes & Gardens printed a reader's recipe and left the name Paul on it. When the magazine's food editor ran it again years later, under a headline promising that leftovers were unlikely, she said only that it had come from a reader and that the staff had never found a pumpkin bar they liked as well.1 That is the entire file.
Everything else is legend. Legend has it the year was 1976.2 The rumor mill says his full name was Paul Rainbow, which sounds made up, except that one baker working from a page her mother saved thanks him by exactly that name.3 Some say he was an accountant who got written up in a column about men who cook. Some say he retired to Palm Springs, which is certainly where I'd go.
Others tell it differently. One family is sure the bars are named for their own Paul, a dad who loved them. Another handed the recipe down for a generation and admits to having no idea where it came from. And plenty of people make them every fall without ever hearing the name.
I'm going with the accountant, because it's the only version that explains the recipe. The numbers are round and nothing is left over. It calls for one whole can of pumpkin, not three-quarters of one. The man balanced a sheet cake.
If you knew Paul, or if you are Paul: I have questions.
Quick answers
- What are Paul's Pumpkin Bars?
- A cinnamon-spiced pumpkin sheet cake, baked in a jelly-roll pan, spread with a thin coat of cream cheese frosting, topped with pecans and cut into 24 bars. It is a reader recipe that Better Homes & Gardens printed, by every account in 1976.
- Who was Paul?
- Nobody knows for certain. The magazine credited only a reader. The most repeated rumor is that he was Paul Rainbow, an accountant who later retired to Palm Springs.
- Do you grease the pan?
- No. The magazine's recipe calls for an ungreased 15×10×1-inch pan. Some later versions grease it, and the bars come out either way.
- Can I bake them in a 9×13 pan?
- Yes. The same batter in a 9×13 pan makes thicker, cakier bars and takes about 30 minutes at 350°F.
- What size can of pumpkin do I need?
- One 15-ounce can of plain pumpkin purée, not pumpkin pie filling. The magazine's recipe says a 16-ounce can, which was the standard size at the time.
- How long do they take?
- About 20 minutes of hands-on work, 25 to 30 minutes in a 350°F oven, and roughly an hour to cool before frosting.
- How many bars does it make, and how many calories?
- One pan makes 24 bars at about 260 calories each, by the magazine's count, with pecans and the original thin frosting.
- Can I leave out the pecans?
- Yes. Several long-running versions of the recipe treat them as optional or skip them entirely.
- Do pumpkin bars need to be refrigerated?
- Yes, once frosted. The magazine says to store leftovers in the refrigerator because of the cream cheese frosting.
Evidence
From real pans.